Startseite  Oberaussem   Kriege  2. Weltkrieg   Halifaxbomber abgestürzt  Elisabeth Brüggen   Die Geschichte der Crew  Dokumentation  The Rest of the Story

The Rest of the Story

Hans Griese

On February 9, 2007, a man by the name of John Anton from Saskatoon, Saskatchewan phoned Alma Mendenhall and told her he was doing research, looking for information on a crashed Halifax in Germany, he came across this internet site: http://

www.stadtteilforum- oberaussem.de/de/projekte/fortlaufende-projekte/oberaussemfrueher/2-weltkrieg/absturz-eines-halifaxbombers/. He told Alma that there was a group of people in Oberaussem Germany who created this site and were trying to piece

together missing information about a Halifax RG455 that had crashed in the back yard of Mrs. Elizabeth Bruggen 62 years ago. Originally these people thought it was the crash site of a different plane from the 427 RCAF squadron, but later found that it was Gibb’s plane from the 432 RCAF squadron. Alma contacted me and I began to correspond with these people from Oberaussem. Hans Griese, in years past came across a diary of Elisabeth Brüggen, now deceased, which talked about a Halifax war plane crashing in her back yard in 1945. This began the search for Hans. He became very interested in discovering the rest of the story. Because Hans does not speak English well I am mostly in communication with his son Sven and Bjoern who do speak English. The following is correspondence made with them and John Anton.

January 29, 2007

Hello John,

I am pleased, which her us on our Internet side visited and here got the information about the fallen Halifax. For some days we know, what for a bomber fell and the names of the crew members know. Afterwards Halifax VII RG 455 coded QO-X fell squadron 432 from yorkshire east moorland in Bergheim Oberaussem, Kirchstrasse 47 burning.

F/O E. Patzer, killed Gt. C. Grant, RAF killed F/O G. Henson RCAF -POW F or the like May, RCAF POM P/O F. Daly, RCAF -POW F/Sgt. J. Mcintosh RCAF -POW W.G.

Mendenhall RCAF killed It does wrong to me that I cannot help you in. But perhaps you can help me. I am very much interested in the fate of the survivors. Where could I experience over it something? Since I speak only completely little English, I let automatic translate the side. I hope that you understand everything well. In this sense all property and cordial greetings

Hans Griese

 

From: "Hans Griese" <[email protected]>

To: "John Anton" <[email protected]>

Subject: AW: HALIFAX RG455 - QO-X

Date: Mon, 5 Feb 2007 14:44:00 +0100

 

Hello John,

it is a fact, that on 21 February 1945, 02:00 -03: 00 o'clock the 432 Halifax VII

RG455 QO-X fell stationed in East moorland/Yorkshire after an air raid on Monheim, in Bergheim Oberaussem, Kirchstrasse 47 burning into the garden. Three crew members were killed. Among other things FO E F Patzer, RCAF. I am interested in all facts, which

there are in this connection and this will use, in order to arrange an extensive Internet presentation for this topic. Began I already. Here is the address.

Cordial greetings

Hans Griese

 

Von: John Anton [mailto:[email protected]]

Gesendet: Sonntag, 4. Februar 2007 19:11

An: [email protected]

Betreff: HALIFAX RG455 - QO-X

Dear Hans

I have some progress to report.The pilot Edwin Patzer came from the town of Yorkton not far from here.I have contacted people who know of him and am waiting for more information. Before the war he was a hockey player for a team called "THE YORKTON

TERRIERS".He also played hockey for the RCAF team while in the airforce.There is a

Lake in northern Saskatchewan named in his memory, "Patzer Lake".I will send more information later. I may also have contact with the family of J . McIntosh who was a POW at Stalag Luft 1, I am hopefull that he may be a crewmember? I hope I am correct that the aircraft you have discovered is RG455??

Best wishes

John Anton

 

Von: John Anton [mailto:[email protected]]

Gesendet: Mittwoch, 7. Februar 2007 14:57

An: [email protected]

Betreff: FW: Re: Halifax RG455 codeQO-X

Hans

I am sorry to report that the J. McIntosh in Revelstoke is not the one we are looking for. I have given information about your project to the Royal Canadian Legion here in Saskatoon and also to the magazine that is published by the Legion.I hope some of the

war veterans who recieve the magazine may send you information about the crew.

Best wishes

John

 

To: <[email protected]>

Sent: Sunday, February 04, 2007 8:10 AM

Subject: Halifax RG455 codeQO-X

Sir

My name is John Anton from Saskatoon Sask. and I am trying to help find crew or

family of the aircraft above.A group at Monheim Germany is excavating the crash site and hopes to create a memorial to the crew.If you were a crewmember or have any knowlage about this crew Pilot Edwin Patzer of Yorkton,C. Grant,G. Henson,A. May, F.Daley, F/Sgt. J. McIntosh and W. Mendenhall please contact me by return E-mail and I

can put you in contact with the people doing the project. Please excuse me if you are not the McIntosh I am looking for.

Best wishes

John Anton

 

Hello Thom,

I am lucky over John Anton contact to you and thus to a member to have gotten.

History can be finally written to end. I wait for a new message of you.

Yours sincerely

Hans Griese

 

 

Von: Thom Evanson [mailto:[email protected]]

Gesendet: Samstag, 10. Februar 2007 00:20

An: [email protected]

Betreff: Hello

Hans Griese

My name is Thom Evanson. I live in Southern Alberta. I just finished talking to John Anton on the phone. I can’t tell you how excited I was to hear about your interest in Halifax RG 455 which crashed in Germany on February 21 around 0200. My Uncle Gibb Mendenhall was one of the crew members that was killed in this crash. I have been doing research on this for a number of years now and have articles and photos. I am very very interested in anything you are doing there. I looked at your site but can not

read German so I will find a translator. John has sent me your correspondence to him. I am also in correspondence with Burke MacIntosh who is still alive living in Nova Scotia.

He was the rear gunner and bailed out before the plane hit the ground. My mother is an older sister to Gibb Mendenhall. Gibb was a mid upper gunner in RG 455. I hope you are able to read this. I will write more once I receive a return email from you.

Thom Evanson

 

Hi Thom!

I am Sven, the son of Hans. He asked me to write to you because his English isn´t really the best. Ok, let me first tell you about the reason for our research. My father and some other people from his Group are very interested in the history of our Village, especially the things happened around World War II. So, they came across a letter from a wife who was a child in 1945. She was living in the house where the Halifax nearly

crashed in. She wrote down the impressions from this night in her diary. So, this was the reason why my father began searching for Details. At first we started really slowly, because there aren´t much people living from this time and it was hard to become some facts. Because the wife who wrotes the letter was a child in this time, we weren ´t sure about the truth of the facts she wrote. So we tried to discover the type of plane. It wasn´t really easy... We are working together with a group from Euskirchen, not far from us. They are specialized in digging out crashed planes from WW2. We found some parts that were definitely from a Halifax Bomber. So, the type was

discovered. Now we began to find the correct plane. The group from Euskirchen have good contacts to England. They asked for all Bombers crashed at this day in our county. So, we were able to find out about the crew and some other facts. And it is like a wonder that John Anton came along my fathers website at this time. With your help my father will be able to bring this project to an end.

Ok, what he is searching for are all the facts and backgrounds from this time. He is looking forward to put all facts together and put them into his website. So everyone will be able to read about the things happened in this night and the years after it. It would be interesting for us what happened to the crew members who became POW.

Believe me, i´m sure that over 70% of the people who are living here didn´t know about this plane and all the other things which happened here in this time. And with every person dying from those days we are losing facts and the knowledge about this history. So, it is the ambition for my father to search about the truth. Every picture you have or articles would be welcome! So we can put all together and the truth will never

die... I attach some pictures to this E-Mail. They show us by digging out some

fragments of RG455. I say thank you for your efforts in advance! We are really happy with this partnership! This is what my father was searching for a long time. So, we are waiting for your response.

Greets,

Sven Griese

 

 

 

Looking for Halifax 455 Pieces of Aircraft found

Hi Thom!

Believe me, it´s a pleasure for us too, working together with you! It´s really intersting how things come together today. Some years ago the contacts over such big distances were much more difficult. But for me it´s good that the enemies from those days now work together as friends. Me, I´m too young and I don´t know much from those days,

except the things I read about. But it´s exciting for me to be a little part in rebuilding the history. My father is so happy with this partnership you couldn´t believe. I was on phone with him a few minutes ago and told him from your answer. Believe me he is really excited about the whole situation. He was sure all the time, that he could discover the truth about the plane and the crew. You and your family are welcome to visit us and the crash site. The body’s of the fallen crew members where buried at our

local cemetery first before they where moved to their graves at the Rheinberg

cemetery. I´m sure it would be interesting and emotional for you and your nephews to be on all those places. As is say you are welcome.

My father talked to the owner of the land where RG455 crashed and he is also very interested to invite you for a visit. Contact me for more details in this event. Now we wait for you to come back from USA and your answer. Hope you had a nice time on

your journey!

Regards,

Sven

Translation made by Sven Griese. From German to English February 25, 2007

 

Four engine Halifax-Bomber fallen

On February 21st 1945, between 02:00 and 03:00 clock in the morning, a Halifax

Bomber, burning over Oberaussem, fell and crashed onto the property of Peter Brüggen of “Cemetery Road 14”.

The now deceased Elisabeth Brüggen wrote down her impressions from this night into a letter. Gaby Brüggen, kindly gave up this document to us. Probably the bomber was hit by a flak gun from Königsdorf and after drifted over to Oberaussem. Other people thought that the bomber was hit by flak positioned at the Schlungweg. Of the seven crewmembers, two have been located dead, a third person was taken POW. He landed on the “Ostkippe” which is called “Abtsbusch” today. The

following day, he gave up himself to German soldiers at the flak position on the opposite of Asperschlag. The fate from the other crew members is not known. In the middle 50’s the wrecked plane was dug out and scrapped.

Memories of Elisabeth Brüggen

Oberaussem, 18.03.1945

“On the night from the 19th to 20th

of February in the year 1945 we were

awakened by a horrible noise. It was

between 1 and 2 o'clock in the night.

There was lightning, a horrible noise, and

burning in our yard and also the

neighbour's. Burning was everywhere I

looked. Our father was on nightshift. Last

noon we received two soldiers in our house for quartering. I called them and we started fighting the fire. The three of us were fighting like crazy, till one of the

soldiers said, “this is a crashed plane”. It

was crashed into our garden burning. It

was like a wonder that no one of us was

hurt. We couldn't get up where the plane

was crashed, because there was still some

ammo which exploded all the time. Our

garden gate was thrown onto the roof,

and caused some damage up there and

then fell in front of the yard gate. The

plane exploded and was shredded into

thousands of little pieces. Every little piece was still burning. I felt like I was burning also. It was a Halifax. Two dead people where discovered, one had jumped out of the plane, and was a POW later. About the fate of the others nothing is known. But our garden was destroyed. On this day we were the most important people. I had never seen such a migration through Oberaussem ever.”

 

Eyewitness Heinrich Wintz

The eyewitness of Heinrich Wintz observed on this night from his work place, how a parachute flew towards the ground. Taken from “Memories from the time of World War 2 in Oberaussem” from Sofie Kamp.

Inscribed by Ulrich Reimann in August 2006.

“For Sofie Kamp,an unforgettable experience from this, for the needy population, a difficult time, is in relation to the crash of an allied bomber on the night of the 19th to 20th of February, 1945. A four engine English bomber, probably shot down by the German Anti-air Command, fell this night burning with a horrible noise into the garden

of the family Brüggen on the “Cemetery Road”. Apparently one of the crew was able to jump off with his parachute before the plane, coming from the direction of Cologne, crashed down. He landed on the area of the “Ostkippe” (this is a forest today). Heinrich Wintz, the father of Sofie Kamp, who worked this night on the “Ostkippe” as switchman, observed the jump and the landing of the soldier. He viewed where the soldier covered his parachute and lifejacket, before he tiptoed away. After a little time

Heinrich Wintz had the guts to go to the hiding place. The soldier was gone. He put the parachute and the lifejacket in an new hiding place. On the day after, he picked up the things and brought them to his home. In a time of material need, there were made clothes from the parachute silk for the whole family Wintz. Sofie herself got a blouse from this, which she wore a long time after the war and it was simply indestructible.

From the fate of the bailed soldier Sofie only knows that he was caught close to the “Property Asperschlag”. The police officer Esser brought him to his cell inside the basement of the old school in Oberaussem at the “Bergheimer Road” for one night. At the next day the Gestapo picked him up. Anyway, nobody heard about the fate of this man.”

 

In the beginning there was a question

 

In the beginning there was a question...

What happened the night a bomber crashed, burning in the area where the family of

Peter Brüggen lived?

What type of plane was this?

Where did it come from and what happened to the crew?

 

Is it still possible to answer these questions 60 years after it happened?

Yes, it is possible to get answers after 60 years!

But how is this possible?

Because Elisabeth Brüggen wrote down her impressions from this night 3 weeks later. We know about the facts, and know that an English Halifax Bomber crashed, burning in the garden. Two crew members died in this crash. One crew member was able to bail out with his parachute. He was caught by a soldier from an anti-air gun opposite of the property “Asperschlag” the next day.

Although the wreckage was dug out in the early 50's and the aluminum parts were

scrapped, it is still possible to find small pieces in the earth. Through these parts it is possible to discover if it was a Halifax Bomber or not. During the last years the English military released many facts from the time of WW2.

Through some websites it is possible to investigate this information. So, it is possible to discover quickly the number of crashed planes for the date of February 20th 1945. In many cases it's established where those planes fell and what happened to the crew members, therefore the number of eligible planes was reduced to a minimum. After first

cognitions, the following Halifax could be the one we are searching for. But for this it still needs some research.

 

 

20./ 21.02.45: Squadron 427, Halifax III coded NP942 ZL-T 2147 stationed in Leeming, operational area on 20.02.1945 Monheim.

 

 

FLt J M Murphy RCAF POW

Sgt G B Tate POW

FO G F Mann RCAF POW

FO E Essenburg RCAF KIA

WO2 E A Perdue RCAF POW

FO A J Breault RCAF POW

PO J M Wallace RCAF KIA

 

On October 10th 2005 Peter Brüggen found, through a little excavation in his garden, some small parts of the wreck and put them aside.

 

The Identification

The identification is now clarified since January 2007. It is 100% positive that the

fallen plane is the Halifax VII RG455 coded QO-X. This bomber was used on February

20th 1945 during a large bombing raid against the Rhenania Ossag Oil at Monheim.

The Halifax Bomber was built in England but the crew members were all from Canada.

 

20-21/02/45 432 Halifax VII RG455 QO-X East Moor FO E F Patzer RCAF 2213

Monheim Killed

20-21/02/45 432 Halifax VII RG455 QO-X East Moor Sgt C I Grant 2213 Monheim Killed

20-21/02/45 432 Halifax VII RG455 QO-X East Moor FO G B Henson RCAF 2213

Monheim PoW

20-21/02/45 432 Halifax VII RG455 QO-X East Moor FO A H May RCAF 2213 Monheim PoW

20-21/02/45 432 Halifax VII RG455 QO-X East Moor PO F S Daley RCAF 2213 Monheim PoW

20-21/02/45 432 Halifax VII RG455 QO-X East Moor FSgt J W B McIntosh RCAF 2213

Monheim PoW

20-21/02/45 432 Halifax VII RG455 QO-X East Moor FSgt W G Mendenhall RCAF 2213 Monheim Killed

Result

 

Summarizing and bringing it to a point it can be said that this night, the night of the February 21st 1945, there was a large air raid against Germany, in which hundreds of Halifax bombers were involved. The crashed Halifax VII GR455 QO-X was from Squadron

432, stationed at Eastmoor Yorkshire/UK. The seven crew members were from the

RCAF(Royal Canadian Air Force) and involved in the attack against the oil industry at Monheim.

 

 

How to approach this?

Why should we reinvent the wheel? For years now, there are people who discover

crashed planes and are not satisfied until the identification is 100% sure.

 

 

Since the beginning of 2006, the “City forum”(Stadtteilforum)” have been working together with the research group “Luftkriegsgeschichte”. On March 2006 Hans Günther Ploes and Jürgen Bock scanned the crash-site for the smallest parts.

 

You can learn more about the research group „Luftkriegsgeschichte“ here: www.agluftkriegsgeschichte-kreis-euskirchen.de

 

March 27, 2006

Searching with the Metal Detector

On Sunday, March 18, 2006 the time had come. Experts Hans Günther Ploes and Jürgen

Bock from the research group “Luftkriegsgeschichte Rhein/Mosel e.V.” came with their

detectors. They scanned the ground meticulously, centimeter by centimeter, where the

Halifax Bomber had crashed 61 years earlier, in the hope of finding some small parts

which might help to identify it. The detector sounded with a fine “beep” that there was

metal in the ground. The probe head was moved over the target crosswise to identify

it. A few seconds after this the commando “HERE” was called. A cut with a spade was

made on the target, and the search for the metal parts began. There was often only

small aluminum parts under the layer of the grass, which showed up after repeatedly

breaking up the clumps. These were collected in a plastic bag. If the metal parts were

deeper in the ground it was necessary to dig deeper. The small parts are very

important. Often the allies used unit numbers for many small parts of an airplane, which

makes it easier today to identify a crashed plane. After cleaning up the parts and

removing the residue of the corrosion, the eye of an expert can identify the small

numbers on the unit.

The Result

It was possible to uncover some marks on the backside of a bullet casing, which were definitely from English ammunition during World War 2 and which were used on Halifax Bombers as well.

It was obviously a Halifax Bomber, so the research continued on. It was our assumption that there were more parts in the ground.

Summarizing it can be said, that the evidence showed that it was really a Halifax Bomber which fell here in Oberaussem. This is really important,

because now we are able to research more precisely.

 

Delay

Because of construction, the research has stopped for a while. As soon as this construction work is completed, the research will go on. The fate of the crew is not known at the moment.

The fact is, two crew members died and were buried at the cemetery in Oberaussem. Another crew member obviously gave himself up to German

soldiers at the manor of “Asperschlag”.

 

When the Bomber is definitely identified it makes sense to investigate the fate of the

 

crew!

 

On 25-Feb-07, at 10:16 PM, Thom Evanson wrote:

Hi Kay

Hopefully you received the translation that Sven sent me. I asked him to translate it into English so I could understand it. I will send it again. We were wondering if Burke was the man that Heinrich Wintz saw land in the parachute and if he wasn't which crew member he thinks it might be?

Thom

 

On 26-Feb-07, at 9:38 AM, kayMcIntosh wrote:

Anyway what a really tremendous message from you this morning. Burke is absolutely amazed and so grateful for bringing him this last episode of his last flight. You have been able to amass so much of the minutest details. I don't believe we received these before, at least about the use of the parachute.

We did get from you an insertion to get the german language story.

 

 

We even got a good laugh at the use of the parachute to make clothes for the family.

Great!

 

A few changes from Burke's memory.

Yes, he was the one who landed, hid his parachute in a brook and covered it with sods. Then he went into a wooded area and slept for the rest of the night. In the morning he was wakened by a group of Polish women on their way to dig ditches for the Germans.

One of the last of these saw Burke ,who was lying quietly hoping not to be seen, and said to him "Alo estrange" She went down a hill and told the ' wermach'(sp?) two german soldiers, who not knowing if he was dead or alive, went up the hill to see without their guns. When they found him they asked if he wished to go to the

hospital. When Burke said no, he was fine, they took him by the arm and down the hill to get their guns.

They then took him into a small nearby town and turned him over to two blackshirted policemen. An office of authority rode up to them on a bike. He had on a long brown coat swastika on his arm and his hat. He aimed his gun to shoot but the german soldier

stood between them to prevent him from shooting Burke. The airmen had been told that they would scare them first then ask questions.

They then turned him over to interrogation officers.

As you can see this coincides with their remembrances with a few minor changes.

Thanks a million again Thom.

Kay

 

Oberaussem Germany. Arrow show where the crash site is